Filters: What would you choose?

[JasonC]

Slap a 2262 on it and call it done!!!!

[myjohnson]

Do both for best results.

Only downside to a wet/dry is a little noise but there are ways around that.

[LIB]

WOW! Since I'm single and need a filter system......I could get both??????

LIB

[CajunAg]

And they make you rubberized and bullet proof.

And make you much more attractive to the opposite sex b/c of you cunning DIY skillz :)

[fshfrk]

And they make you rubberized and bullet proof.

[CajunAg]

Wet-drys/sumps do offer some advantages that tipped the scales away from canisters for me:

1) Hide all of your heaters, probes, thermometers, anything else that normally goes in the tank and sticks out like a sore thumb. Now, Rena does make some pretty good in-line heaters for canister use, so that should be considered
2) Extra water volume = makes it easier on the water chemistry and increases O2 saturation
3) Cost. A DIY sump can be easily, quickly, and cheaply made for less than the cost of a new canister. Home Depot/Lowes pretty much sells everything you'll need to make a basic one
4) My favorite: once up and running, the water level in the main tank is constant. No more hard water lines on the glass where you can see them!

[fshfrk]

Come to the GHAC meeting at my house on Saturday night. I will show you a wet/dry or 2. I just shut down my last cannister tonight and I'm extremely happy and will be for years to come. LOL. A can and a W/D would be perfect for you since a HOB is not a option.

[IvanSanchez]

Eheim 2217. +1
You gotta figure out your stock list for that tank before you buy more than one filter.

[JasonC]

I'll +1 the 2217 suggestion. Awesome filters.

Don't skimp on the filtration. It's the one area that you want top of the line.

[LIB]

Sorry about the 'powder' vs 'power' but at least we all smiled, uh?

WOW! Am I learning a bunch here. You guys are terrific. I appreciate the info and opinions. Have to do some digging on the net and read up on these filters. Keep the suggestions coming.

LIB

[myjohnson]

wait....does fish powder get you high?

If so....pm me.

[sunkenmetal]

I didnt catch the powder part either, if i had I would be asking, "What is this fish powder you speak of " :)

its all good

[jhouk]

I didnt catch the powder part either, if i had I would be asking, "What is this fish powder you speak of " :)

[sunkenmetal]

I am sure someone will correct me if I am mistaken. I was under the impression that even a wet/dry requires power by using a pump to return the water to the tank.

LOL read the thread he said Powder...... So I said it doesn't need powder.....

[jhouk]

A wet dry doesn't need powder......

I am sure someone will correct me if I am mistaken. I was under the impression that even a wet/dry requires power by using a pump to return the water to the tank.